Sample report for benefits advisors

What Highmark pays Pittsburgh hospitals

Highmark commercial plans rates at 11 hospitals within 30 miles of Pittsburgh, for 25 common outpatient services: imaging, lab tests and emergency visits. Every figure below is a line in that hospital's own published price file, linked at the bottom, so you can check any number before you rely on it.

Prepared November 15, 2026. First report for a client is free; then $490 per report or $299 a month for up to 25 clients.

Widest price spreads for the same service

Same insurer, same service, same metro. The spread is the highest rate divided by the lowest, across the hospitals that publish a usable rate for it.

ServiceLowestHighestArea medianSpread
MRI brain, without and with contrast9 hospitals$413Advanced Surgical Hospital$3,627Upmc Mercy$2,0788.8x
MRI pelvis, without and with contrast9 hospitals$413Advanced Surgical Hospital$3,019Upmc Mercy$7877.3x
Basic metabolic panel11 hospitals$10.10Advanced Surgical Hospital$65.66Upmc East$18.676.5x
Comprehensive metabolic panel11 hospitals$12.61Advanced Surgical Hospital$82.01Upmc East$23.306.5x
Hepatic function panel11 hospitals$9.75Advanced Surgical Hospital$63.38Upmc East$18.036.5x
MRI brain, without contrast9 hospitals$280Advanced Surgical Hospital$1,711Upmc Mercy$5386.1x

The PDF has all 25 services, with every hospital's rate and what other insurers pay at the same hospital.

Hospitals, most expensive first

Hospitals in one health system usually share a contract, so they are grouped. The index is how the group's rates compare with the area median across the services it publishes: 1.40 means 40% above.

1.30x

area median

Upmc Passavant

Above the area median on 14 of 24 services.

1.29x

area median

Upmc St Margaret

Above the area median on 18 of 24 services.

1.24x

area median

Upmc Mckeesport Hospital

Above the area median on 17 of 24 services.

1.19x

area median

Upmc East

Above the area median on 19 of 25 services.

1.02x

area median

Upmc Mercy

Above the area median on 13 of 25 services.

1.00x

area median

Excela Health Westmoreland Regional Hospital

Above the area median on 5 of 19 services; above what other insurers pay there on 5 of 19.

0.97x

area median

St Clair Hospital

Above the area median on 9 of 23 services; above what other insurers pay there on 7 of 23.

0.71x

area median

Heritage Valley Sewickley; Heritage Valley Beaver

Above the area median on 2 of 10 services; above what other insurers pay there on 5 of 5.

0.63x

area median

Ahn Wexford Hospital

Above the area median on 1 of 13 services; above what other insurers pay there on 5 of 13.

0.54x

area median

Advanced Surgical Hospital

Above the area median on 3 of 16 services; above what other insurers pay there on 5 of 16.

How clients use it

A self-funded employer pays its hospital claims with its own money. The report shows which hospitals cost the plan more for the same service, which helps with steering, network design and the renewal conversation with the carrier or TPA. Rates are as published in each hospital's file for this insurer's commercial plans. A client's specific network or product may differ.

Method and limits

  • It compares unit prices, not claims. Carve-outs, stop-loss and outlier terms are not in the numbers.
  • Only fee-schedule dollar rates are used. If the same plan also pays a service as a percentage of charges, a case rate or a per diem at a hospital, that service is left out for that hospital.
  • Prices are per code, outpatient, facility fee only. Packaging and multiple-procedure discounts are not modeled.
  • Commercial plans only: plans a hospital names as Medicare, Medicaid or exchange products are left out. Where a hospital lists several plans for the insurer, its figure is the middle one (the lower of the two middle ones when the count is even), so every figure is a line in the file.
  • Implausible lines are dropped, and so are hospitals whose files don't hold up. Comparisons use medians, and a health system's shared contract counts once.

Sources

Each hospital's standard charges file, as published under 45 CFR 180, and the date the hospital put on it.

  • Advanced Surgical HospitalWashington, 23.2 mi, file dated Invalid Datefile
  • Ahn Wexford HospitalWexford, 13.3 mi, file dated April 14, 2026file
  • Excela Health Westmoreland Regional HospitalGreensburg, 25.9 mi, file dated Invalid Datefile
  • Heritage Valley BeaverBeaver, 26.2 mi, file dated March 27, 2026file
  • Heritage Valley SewickleySewickley, 11.7 mi, file dated March 27, 2026file
  • St Clair HospitalPittsburgh, 6 mi, file dated Invalid Datefile
  • Upmc EastMonroeville, 12.6 mi, file dated Invalid Datefile
  • Upmc Mckeesport HospitalMc Keesport, 10.8 mi, file dated Invalid Datefile
  • Upmc MercyPittsburgh, 0.9 mi, file dated Invalid Datefile
  • Upmc PassavantPittsburgh, 7.9 mi, file dated Invalid Datefile
  • Upmc St MargaretPittsburgh, 6.3 mi, file dated Invalid Datefile

Have a client renewing soon?

Pick the metro and carrier and the PDF arrives in about a minute, or we tell you on screen that the data there is too thin. The first report is free; then $490 per report or $299 a month for up to 25 clients. Invoices are fine: email [email protected].

Get a free Network Price Check

Other published samples: Dallas-Fort Worth, Chicago, Los Angeles, Phoenix, Philadelphia. Not legal, financial or contracting advice.